OUR SITES: Centre for Sustainable Healthcare | Sustainable Action Planning | NHS Forest | Mapping Greener Healthcare | Carbon Addict

Baling and Recycling of Bottles & Cardboard

By: Newcastle Upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

£7,384 net savings (Actual)

85.2 tonnes CO2e (Estimated)

The Renal Unit produces huge amounts of waste plastic and cardboard during its clinical activities. In order to recycle this waste the Trust installed two new pieces of equipment. A cardboard baler was installed to service the whole Freeman Hospital site in March 2011, which allowed the Renal Unit’s cardboard to be baled and recycled. In November 2011 a smaller twin baler was also installed to crush and bale the segregated 5L acid bottles from each renal dialysis session. Cardboard and plastic bottle recycling has increased by over 90 tonnes and savings of over £7,000 have been achieved.

The project was initiated by consultant nephrologist, Dr Alison Brown, and modern matron, Julia Harding. Using the commitment shown by the renal department, the Trust Waste Officer was able to justify a business case and gain Executive approval.

Equipment comprises a Static Vertical Mill Sized Baler (MX600) on long term rental for cardboard, and a twin chamber compact baler (Compact 75) on two-year rental for dialysis 5L plastic bottles. Baled cardboard and bottles are collected by SITA UK (the Trust's general waste contractor).

 

Environmental Benefits

An estimated 12 tonnes of plastic bottle waste is produced by the renal department each year.  Recycling all of this will save approximately 3.168 tonnes CO2e per year (1).

The renal unit has also been contributing its flattened cardboard to the main Freeman Hospital cardboard baler.  Approximately 100 tonnes of cardboard waste is produced annually and recycling this saves an estimated 82 tonnes CO2e per year (2). Unfortunately we are not able to break this down to the specific amount of cardboard produced by the Renal Unit as all areas of the hospital feed into the main cardboard baler. 

Total carbon savings from recycling of plastic and cardboard are therefore approximately 85.2 tonnes CO2e per year.

Importantly, recycling materials also reduces the need for virgin resources for new products. Although the benefits of this are hard to quantify, we know that increasing the recycling of resources instead of just disposing of them makes sense.

Furthermore, the compaction saves on CO2e emissions from large waste vehicle movements, since the much smaller volumes can be more easily stored and therefore collected less frequently. 

(1)This is based on -230 kg CO2e per tonne of plastic recycled vs 34 kg CO2e per tonne of plastic sent to landfill (Annex 9, DEFRA 2011 Greenhouse Gas Conversion Factors for Company Reporting) 

(2) This is based on -240 kg CO2e per tonne of cardboard recycled vs 580 kg CO2e per tonne of cardboard sent to landfill (Annex 9, DEFRA 2011 Greenhouse Gas Conversion Factors for Company Reporting) 

 

Financial Benefits

The financial savings are summarised below:

Waste Type

Predicted Annual Weight of Waste

Previous Total Disposal Costs

New Annual Baler Rental

New Disposal Costs

New Total Annual Costs

Net costs

Plastic Bottles

12t

£720

£1,456

-£540

£916

£196

Cardboard

100t

£6,000

£2,920

-£4,500

-£1,580

-£7,580

Totals

112t

£6,720

£4,376

-£5,040

-£664

-£7,384

To reduce the environmental impact and cost of waste disposal. The project was inspired by an early Green Nephrology case study: http://map.sustainablehealthcare.org.uk/heart-england-nhs-foundation-trust/diversion-waste-recycling-stream-through-use-baling-machines .

SITA UK (long term lease of cardboard baler; collection and rebate for baled cardboard and plastic). Local firm ATK Equipment (2-year lease of plastic bottle baler).

01/03/2011
ongoing

The project was the winner of the Green Nephrology Awards 2012; the award entry poster can be downloaded here.

£4,376 (annual rental costs for balers)

Initial barriers included problems with siting the balers (H&S, fire risk, electrical enabling works, delivery, access etc) and porter buy-in for carrying out the baling tasks. All barriers were overcome through effective communication and options analysis. Beneficial drivers (cost and environmental savings) allowed us to convince all parties that it was the right thing to do. The barriers did place time delays on the project initiation but once approved and installed the successes have demonstrated it was worthwhile.

Problems that arose following implementation have mainly focused on contamination of the bottles resulting in residue on the baler (and difficult working conditions for the porters). This was overcome by showing renal staff the importance of rinsing and emptying all bottles before disposal. We also arranged a full service and clean of the twin baler and this issue hasn't been raised since. To date there have been no issues with the cardboard baler.

James Dixon, Trust Waste Officer, James.dixon@nuth.nhs.uk, 0191 282 1543